X instigates Y to murder Z. Y in pursuance of the instigation stabs Z who recovers from the wound. Which one of the following statement is correct?

• A. Y is liable for attempt to murder and X is liable for abetment of attempt to murder.
• B. Y is guilty of attempt to murder and x is guilty of abetment of murder.
• C. Y is guilty of attempt to murder and X is guilty of no offence
• D. X is guilty of attempt to murder and Y is guilty of offence.